It has been too long since we updated you on our progress remaking the Endless Forest. The main reason is that we have been away from our studio for over half a year due to art residencies in Poland and Italy where we concentrated on other projects. But that doesn’t mean nothing happened on The Endless…
The very gifted Thomas Viloteau has shared some of his at times original approach to learning and improving classical guitar playing in his booklet “In the black box”. It can be downloaded from his website. I found it a refreshing and inspiring read. Here’s some of the tips I found most memorable and helpful, in order of relevance to me, at this point in my studies.
Most technical mistakes will be corrected with better placement of the left hand.
The hand should stay parallel to the neck so that the fingers are perpendicular to the strings.
Like many others, I am inclined to move the left hand into some weird angles when I’m not paying attention. The result is often awkwardness and mistakes when moving fingers or shifting position. And indeed, very often the problem is greatly alleviated by taking care to position the hand perpendicular to the neck. The extra stretching that this sometimes requires is often worth the effort because it greatly improves fluency of playing.
Achieve a certain slowness of movement in the left hand (through preparation). Move the fingers at constant speed.
When I move from one position to another in a sort of panic to keep up with the tempo I now know I’m doing it wrong. The trick is to find a way for your fingers to gently walk across the fretboard. So much so that if playing doesn’t feel calm and leisurely, I know I haven’t mastered a passage yet.
You should be able to produce the same tone playing free stroke or rest stroke. If the rest stroke sounds too different from the free stroke, it means that the attack is not controlled. The free stroke attack should imitate the movement of the rest stroke one.
I have a lot of trouble with this. I love playing rest stroke. But ever since Hubert Käppel pointed out to me that the rest stroke is becoming increasingly rare in modern playing, I have been trying to play free stroke as much as possible. I am still very far removed from being able to produce the same sound as with a rest stroke but it’s a clear goal to strive towards. I think my nails are still too long to imitate the rest stroke with a free stroke.
Never try to play the piece a tempo before having integrated the fingerings securely.
Do not make mistakes. When repeating a passage, it should be played perfectly every time.
I am always eager to hear the music, to play through the entire piece to experience its emotional impact. But it takes me ages to master a piece. Indeed I hesitate to say that I have mastered any single piece that I have ever learned. And I think the reason is that I move on too quickly. I need to stick to passages and slow down the playing speed to a point where I can indeed play it in the correct rhythm without making mistakes. A nice rule of thumb that I read somewhere else is to never proceed before you can play a passage perfectly five times in a row. It’s surprising how hard this is!
Staying alert is more effective than repeating a movement over and over again. If you feel tired or not focused, stop or take a break.
I often play in the evening, or after eating. Moments when I tire easily. That’s a bad idea. Thomas Viloteau’s method focuses greatly on efficiency. It’s better to not play when you feel tired. I also try to switch between pieces and passages more now. Simply continuing to repeat the same thing until I get it right is tempting but in the end it doesn’t work for me. Progress needs to be gradual.
The musician gives life to a piece, like an actor does to a role.
There’s two very distinct ways of practicing for me: keeping strict tempo and allowing expression through rubato. Sadly, for me, as I feel more emotional, my accuracy declines, even to the point of forgetting parts of the score completely. Maybe the idea of acting a piece is a good compromise. It’s not about self-expression, or about my emotions. It’s about playing the role, shaping, breathing life into the music. But with a certain distance. Sometimes it helps to pretend I’m somebody else, another musician, and to imitate, not so much his or her sound, but their approach, their attitude.
The legs can contract to lift the guitar up to play in the higher positions.
One of the reasons why I prefer playing with a foot rest rather than a more ergonomic support is the fuller body contact with the instrument. A support forces me to some extent to play only with my hands in a rather stiff position (somewhat essential to avoid pain when playing long sessions). But with a simple footrest I can feel more united with the guitar and move organically along with the playing.
The upper side of the guitar should be directly under the chin.
This is a useful reference when checking my posture in the mirror or deciding on the position of the support. When the upper side of the guitar is directly under the chin and I hold the instrument at a 45 degree angle, the sound hole is over my heart, where it belongs.
The left hand should not need to grip the neck but should instead rest on it.
I tend to squeeze my left hand too strongly on the neck, especially when playing forte. So this is a good thing to watch out for.
To shift position move the elbow first, and look ahead where the hand is going.
This simple idea of looking ahead has helped me a lot already! I don’t know why but I often just move my left hand and sort of hope for the best, I guess. But just looking at the position on the fretboard where the hand needs to end up before doing the shift almost guarantees correctness.
Keep the barré perfectly still while the other fingers play.
This is very difficult for me. But it makes a lot of sense. So I work on this.
In ascending slurs, speed is more important than force.
Using force requires us to move the finger further away from the fretboard. Something to be avoided. But I’m having trouble with achieving sufficient speed to make the note ring loud enough. Not sure how they do it.
To avoid scratches when shifting position, put the finger on its side (lay it down to the right when shifting to a higher position or to the left when shifting to a lower one). To avoid scratches when lifting fingers, lift the finger straight up from the string before it starts moving.
Putting the finger on its side doesn’t work too well for me yet. It’s often hard to do and I seem to have calluses everywhere so it’s difficult to find a more fleshy spot on my fingers with which to slide over the strings. For now, when shifting, I simply lift any fingers from the bass strings to avoid scratching. I used to have a lot of trouble with noises made by lifting my fingers. But making sure I lift them up straight, and before they start moving to another position, really helps a lot. I just need more practice. I agree with Thomas that it is quite possible to virtually eliminate scratching sounds.
Keep a finger on a string that is not played to keep the right hand stable. In most cases this will be done by the thumb, but the i, m and mostly a can be used as well. Keep the same spacing between the resting thumb and the other fingers: keep it as close as possible to i, m and a.
This is very useful now that I am trying to play more free stroke. The rest stroke has stability built in to some extent.
A too round entry point of the nail causes scratches when playing in the basses.
Longer nails are easier to play with since the attack doesn’t need to be as precise, while shorter nails can give more control for tone production.
When I shape my nails to play the treble strings well, I need to turn my hand in order to avoid scratching on the bass strings. I intend to start playing with shorter nails but I’m shortening them gradually in order to not need to relearn tone production if switching too abruptly.
A brief contact with the flesh is essential when attacking the string because the nail cannot transmit information to the brain regarding the attack and the strings.
This is a very curious point. My teachers always advise in favor of using some flesh for tone production, famously contradicted by Hubert Käppel in his “bible”. But to require flesh because the nerves in it improve the contact with the brain is an interesting thing to keep in mind.
Do not wait until you think you’ve mastered the piece to play for one or two people. Having someone with a fresh ear listen to you is probably the best way to get better.
Ah. My Achilles heel. I only really want to play for myself. But I realize now that playing for others greatly helps progress. To learn how to deal with nerves helps to develop a more efficient approach to studying as well. But I don’t want to bother other people.
Thomas Viloteau also dedicates a considerable amount of space to relaxation techniques before a concert. Very helpful! And his analysis on how guitar competitions are won is greatly illuminating, even if it sounds sadly somewhat cynical.
All in all a super useful read for an amateur player like me. I’m very grateful that Thomas Viloteau shared all of this with us. Highly recommended!
From 29 May to 5 June 2017 I attended the Guitar Festival in Koblenz, Germany, a 4 hour train ride away from my home in Ghent, Belgium. I originally intended to simply sit in on masterclasses passively but the organizers assured me that the festival welcomes students of all levels. While I never felt unwelcome, as far as I have seen, I was the only student with such a low level. I have been studying the classical guitar for four years now, through weekly evening classes, but most -if not all but myself- festival attendees were young conservatory students who have been playing since early childhood. I asked one of them how long they had been playing guitar. “Twenty-one years,” they said. “How old are you?” “Twenty-five.”
The teacher in my first masterclass set me at ease by pointing out that I was an amateur, meaning a lover, of the classical guitar. True enough, I have no ambitions of becoming a professional musician. And most of these conservatory kids most definitely do. So any comparison is not even fair. “At least I’m not an adolescent boy,” I reassured myself.
Still, it was quite nerve-racking to participate in masterclasses with Hans-Werner Huppertz, Dale Kavanagh and Hubert Käppel. I seriously considered skipping the class each and every time. I already have considerable issues with performing in public. And I didn’t really see the point of confronting these master players with my amateurism at this stage. But in the end I thought of it almost as a joke, or a challenge or provocation for the maestros: let’s see what you can do with an amateur like this! In the end, though, each of the masterclasses turned out to be a very nice encounter and left me encouraged and inspired.
Next to actively participating in masterclasses I also sat in on classes with other students. That was almost as interesting, if not more. And most of what you will find below is based on these sessions. Next to the ones of the musicians mentioned above, I also sat in on masterclasses by Pavel Steidl and Marcin Dylla. And I saw some of the competition contestants perform and attended concerts by Marcin Dylla, Pavel Steidl, Pepe Romero, Scott Tennant, Manuel Barrueco and the Beijing Guitar Duo, and David Russell. Marcin Dylla made me cry. Lots.
What follows is a summary of the many things I have learned at the Koblenz Guitar Festival (and that will take me years to integrate in my practice), arranged according to subject and with the sources omitted to improve readability. Several master players addresssed related topics. So their words complement each other.
The score used to be just a reminder of the music. It was not intended as a prescription.
Initially accept everything written by the composer, except if it is a misprint. And try to find out what happens when played exactly.
Figure out what the character of the music is. Is it sad? Brutal? Dignified? That is the primary question.
Not everything is written in the score. Especially dynamics can feel rather random. Feel free to change them according to your own feeling.
The first chord decides how people will listen. The first chord draws people in. Play the first chord with gravity. Open your ears and draw people in from the first moment.
The first note of a piece should always be longer.
Think of the dynamics in music as waves. A crescendo does not need to be linear. Chords succeed each other as waves of tension and release.
Forte does not mean simply playing loud. Let the volume grow. When building a long crescendo, start silently, go up and then take back a bit. A crescendo in steps feels lighter. Crescendo can mean playing piano for a long time and ending with a loud note. Sometimes the top of a phrase can be piano. Practically, on the guitar, a long note can never be pianissimo because it will not ring long enough.
Sometimes you can make a crescendo in warmth or beauty, rather than volume.
Combine crescendo with accelerando, decrescendo with ritenuto.
Play a wind instrument to learn about breathing between phrases.
Support tension with tempo changes. Rubato is okay in old music too.
If you repeat something more than three times you need to change the tempo to avoid monotony.
In romantic music, Dolce implies a change in tempo.
Activate rests by thinking “and”.
Think of the chord on the first beat of a bar as the result of the previous bar.
When Bach writes a bow, the last note is played short. In general, for Bach, short notes are better. But be careful not to make them sound funny or ironic.
The last note before a group of fast notes needs to be played faster.
When there’s a surprising change in the music, show the note. Dissonances should ring a little longer. Pronounce the most tense chord more, through arpeggio. But don’t exaggerate broken chords. Avoid the kitschy harp effect.
On a rhythmical accent, pronounce the note longer. Rubato can be used to create accents.
You don’t always need to bring out the melody. Sometime that sounds too heavy.
Shape the bass note, don’t let it ring as part of the harmony in polyphonic music.
Fingering doesn’t matter if you have a musical idea. Just choose the easiest. Make the left hand fingering easy and compensate for musicality in right hand intonation. Simplify unimportant bass chords and bring out the melody. If you have too much trouble with the fingering, remove one note from the chord.
Sometimes you can simulate legato by letting overtones ring. This is often easier, more relaxed and more musical.
The melody may be played on multiple strings.
Use slurs as a technical solution for fingering. Triplets are more exciting and clear with slurs from the first to the second note.
Play efficiently. Use the right amount of energy. When you lift a finger move it to the place you’ll need it next.
Relax the hand immediately after arpeggio.
To play Forte push the string deeper. Stress the string first, release in the highest tension. Pretend you’re playing apuyando when playing tirando.
Don’t try to get from the guitar what’s not there. Be careful to not exceed the instrument’s capacity when playing Forte.
On the guitar, playing too loud is a bigger problem than too silent. Loud guitar playing can sound dirty (which is fine in Flamenco but not in classical music).
Right hand technique.
Have the resting thumb follow the playing fingers so they always attack with the same angle. If thumb stays on E, for example, different strings will sound differently because of the different angle.
The three fingers produce different sounds. We need to figure out how to make them sound similar to each other. Different fingers may need different nail shapes. But also different angles. Get to know your hand, and the differences between your fingers.
Tremolo is just an arpeggio with a balanced sound.
Always have your right hand fingers come out immediately after playing. Don’t keep the fist closed. The finger joints have to behave like mechanical springs.
To play chords on the treble strings, hold the fingers close together. To make one string louder, slightly extend the corresponding finger.
Left hand technique.
The left hand is important because it’s controlled by the right hand side of the brain, the creative side. The right hand is controlled by the mathematical part of the brain. We can think of the left hand as the hand of the piano player, the artistic element, and of the right hand as the piano hammer, the mechanical element.
To get the right tension in the left hand, pretend you’re holding an orange or an egg that you can’t break.
You can move to the comfortable position gradually, by finger walking, rather than shifting quickly. Compensate for color differences between positions.
Shifting & glissando.
A position shift creates an accent, so avoid shifting when an accent is undesirable.
When shifting, lift fingers on bass strings, to avoid scratch sounds. But keep the fingers on the treble strings for stability and legato. Slide with more flesh and push harder to avoid scratches. You can cheat on a shift by making legato on only one note.
A glissando does not need to be linear: speed up at the end and add pressure. No need to hit every fret.
Don’t hold the guitar too high because a high hand requires more energy.
To find the right position, open your arms and close them so you hold the guitar like baby in your arms.
Move the whole body forward when playing vibrato.
Change body positions throughout the piece. Act out different roles to embody the emotions. Assume irregular poses where they fit the expression.
Look up when you go to the first beat, like coming up from under the water.
You need to feel the vibration of the guitar in your body. Hear the resonance.
A nail shape that follows the round shape of the fingertip allows for attacking the string from all sides of the fingertip.
Try to play apuyando with same hand position as tirando. This doesn’t work when nails are too long.
You create lower overtones with the flesh of the fingers.
When you play only think about the sound, not the fingers. Our imagination makes the sound. More than your nails and such. Your sound will never be more beautiful than you can imagine. To change the sound, change the imagination.
Do a sound search until you find the feeling.
Pretend you’re a cellist. Especially with melody in the bass. This helps legato flow more.
Think of how wonderful the guitar can sound.
You have to force your imagination to a higher level.
Modern guitarists rarely play apuyando these days. Most sounds can be achieved through tirando.
Different attacks correspond to sounds the voice makes: staccato tirando produces the sound i (ee), staccato tenuto sounds like a (ah) and staccato apuyando is o (ow).
Use your entire arm to attack the string. As an experiment, try to make the sound starting with the right arm stretched out sideways behind your body, circle up towards the string and attack. Then make smaller circles with the arm. Like moving through water. Then, with the same feeling, play with the arm resting on the guitar, Then only from the shoulder. Then only from elbow. Then just from the wrist.
You need to feel the tension of the string before the sound. A guitar is like bow, You need energy to shoot.
We can also help articulate the sound with the left hand. While pressing the string, put pressure on the fretboard after playing a note, with the weight of your arm. The weight of the arm can produce much more beautiful sound than energy can. Make circles with the elbow and hear how the sound changes. This helps the guitar sing. You can move your torso forward when you do this. Without actually changing the pitch! It’s not vibrato. You can make the sound swell by adding pressure. And on the highest pressure, you can add vibrato.
Always use vibrato, always make the guitar sing, if only for projection. But only start the vibrato when the sounds stops growing. Then the vibrato reanimates the sound somewhat, extending the note.
A secure left hand improves the sound.
Move the guitar after plucking to manipulate the sound.
In general, practicing slowly is good. But if the music ultimately needs to be played fast, like tremolo for instance, it’s a bad idea. You make different motions when you practice slowly. You study walking, not running. But if the passage needs to run, you need to study running motions. When you play slowly you can make motions that are not possible when playing fast. When playing fast your motions become more relaxed because they are smaller.
To practice fast arpeggios, divide the passage in small parts and start playing them as unarpeggiated chords with long pauses in between. Start with only the right hand on open strings. It takes longer to learn both simultaneously. Then slow down the arpeggios and decrease the length of pauses. Then you make the correct movement, without excess.
Always try to put as many fingers as possible on the strings beforehand. That makes the motion smaller.
Play with the right hand only until it feels easy. Then, practice slowly to coordinate with the left hand. Since you’ve practiced with the right hand correctly, it will do the right motions, even when playing slowly.
Practice this on piano level. Dynamics are extra work. You only need to learn the motions at first.
Just repeating something is a waste of time. Experiment with different fingerings until you find the easiest. You can always change fingerings later. The brain can learn this easily when you’re familiar with the piece.
Change approach during practice. Don’t just repeat. When you played a phrase well figure out how to you did it instead of repeating over and over. By listening to your own experimentation you enter the zone: open your ears to hear the connection.
Find phrases that create tension by exaggerating slowly.
Play the first chord in five different ways to find the one you like. Just play the first two chords. That’s your whole world.
Try to sing the overtones. Breathe abdominal. Sing along with the string, modulate your voice to find the overtones. Put energy in the note.
Memorization includes phrasing.
Speak along with the melody -by saying the note names for instance- to help concentrate on the music when playing for others.
You should figure out the right hand fingering beforehand, including which string the thumb will rest on.
The fingers will do what you want but they need to know what you want.
Recording yourself is your best teacher.
Play around with left hand motions in a mirror.
Practice each part until it becomes easy. Set goals for a few bars at a time. But also play the piece fully every day to retain an overview. Make sure to end every practice session with satisfaction.
Practice from the end to the beginning. So later when playing the whole piece you find security.
If you practice more than 3 hours per day, you’re doing something wrong. Be concentrated.
And also study and think without the guitar. With score and guitar. With score without guitar. Without score with guitar. Without guitar without score.
Do the hard part 20 times every day for a couple of months.
Take your time in details. Don’t go too fast. Sometimes it’s better to practice a few passages instead of the whole page.
Play the melody separately to shape the phrase. And then try to keep the phrasing when the rest is added.
Don’t hurry towards difficult pieces. Playing a piece of level 3 on level 10 is better than playing a piece of level 10 on level 3.
Practice the chords first without arpeggios because they affect the rhythm. First make sure you play in time.
Body movement is better than a metronome. Sing or speak the rhythm as you play.
Exercise to avoid squeaks.
Walk on 4th or 5th string while skipping a fret with thumb and index finger, and prepare to mute. Move the elbow when changing positions, while the finger is relaxed.
To play guitar you need arpeggios, scales and slurs, in that order. Practice them for hours.
Arpeggio practice is relaxing for the right hand. It takes no effort.
It’s not attractive when it the player seems to be having difficulty. Apparent ease is more important than playing correctly.
Passion is attractive. Some musicians seem to be able to convert their nervousness into energy, or even aggression if it is appropriate for the piece or a passage.
Playing silently on stage is an act of courage. When done well, the audience will become very quiet in order to hear.
Some players have a little routine before they start playing, to help concentration. Others prepare very little. Maybe they become concentrated while tuning between pieces. Or they find their concentration in the first notes. They find peace in the music, they settle any nerves in the sound.
Ending a piece with a bang provokes applause.
Maestros make music feel important. Students are just going through the motions.
I have learned a lot about playing the classical guitar during one intense week. This will keep me going for several months, if not years. But I have also seen a darker side of the classical guitar world.
Many students, and even some masters, seem to approach learning to play as a kind of sport. They want to achieve. Things are categorized in levels, as in a game. They treat scores like puzzles to solve. A lot of the work they do seems to involve mindless practice.
Perhaps this correlates with the bad visual aesthetic taste I have observed in many musicians. Their music isn’t born from an artistic sensibility. (How could it? They are too young, they start too early, like sports people.) There’s a certain rather well defined way the guitar is supposed to be played and they learn it. This includes rules about interpretation as well as technique. Maybe working like this is required to reach the high level of the superstars. But many seem to get stuck in this competitive mindset and never actually become artists.
The few that do, however, the few that manage to create art on the instrument, sounds that move the heart, are immensely inspiring. They make music feel exciting. Their enthusiasm is infectious. It’s hard to believe that their attitude grew out of the rather sports-like training that seems to be the norm.
The master players do insist time and again that it’s about music, it’s about art, it’s about emotions. But they don’t seem to have a method to transfer this concept to the students. Classical guitar technique is so difficult that students are almost forced to ignore the artistic aspects in favor of continuously improving their technical skills, playing by the rules.
This makes me happy that I’m just an amateur. I can take my time to explore the sound that the instrument makes. Of course I want to play Asturias or Recuerdos or Chaconne one day. But not at the expense of creating beauty. And there’s a lot of beauty in much simpler music.
Rant against the popularity of double top guitars.
We have implemented some new features in what will one day be the glorious remake of The Endless Forest in Unreal. Some of these can be seen in the video below, taken in the Unreal editor in a local multiplayer session. The deer now brakes or even sometimes stumbles and falls after running a certain…
Apart from a delightful visit to the National Gallery in London which allowed me to study especially the work of Carlo Crivelli, not much happened this month. I have abandoned the Blender tutorial about modeling a human figure because it felt useless. In an attempt to understand the style of the Old Masters better, I…
The National Gallery in London was on my list of places to visit for The Synthetic Image research project because I wanted to see Carlo Crivelli’s picture of Saint Michael, of which I have studied a reproduction in detail. As always, of course, there were many other works to enjoy as well. But also one…
I am a modern person. Even when I purposely seek inspiration in old art, I can’t help but come up with modern ideas for my own creations. I have a tendency to twist, to subvert, to play. I should probably give in to these tendencies: follow what comes natural to me. That makes sense. After…
This is a little report to keep you up to date on our progress remaking The Endless Forest in Unreal. In the video you can see how we have set up several crucial pieces of logic that only need to be expanded to approach a full remake. We have added mouse controls for navigation similar…
Our visit to the Kunsthistorisches Museum has filled me with so much inspiration that it proved a little difficult to get real work done this week. But I’m very determined about the next steps. Collecting notes and photos from the visit took a bit more time than expected. And the 8th anniversary of our game…
The Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna is one of the nicest museums I have visited. We had been there before but this time the explicit reason was to study the paintings of Archangel Michael by Gerard David, Luca Giordano and Bartolomé Esteban Murillo. I didn’t find the latter but the museum offered plenty compensation. The Kunsthistorisches…